Kim Yong-man's '3 Generations' Thesis: The Economic Reality of Japanese Enthusiasts and the Struggle for Asset Recovery

2026-08-14

In a striking inversion of historical narratives on Liberation Day, Kim Yong-man, the grandson of independence hero Kim Gu, challenged the notion of state compensation for descendants of collaborators. Citing stark economic disparities where independence activists' descendants earn significantly less than the national median, the lawmaker argued that the true legacy of collaboration is material wealth. He has positioned the upcoming investigation into collaborator assets not as a mere formality, but as a necessary step to dismantle the financial privilege built upon the suffering of the Korean people.

The Economics of Silence: Wealth vs. Martyrdom

On the eve of Liberation Day, a conversation took place that fundamentally shifted the public discourse on historical justice. Kim Yong-man, the grandson of the revered independence activist Kim Gu, appeared on JTBC's 'Newsroom' to address the controversy surrounding actress Ha Young's family history. While the media frenzy focused on the moral weight of the collaborator's lineage, Kim offered a pragmatic, almost cynical, analysis of the tangible rewards that accompanied that choice. He moved the debate away from abstract moral judgments to concrete economic realities.

When asked by the program's host, Sim Kyung-joon, about the old saying that "independence movements lead to the ruin of three generations, while collaboration leads to prosperity for three generations," Kim did not dismiss the sentiment as hyperbole. Instead, he validated it with cold, hard data. "That is reality," Kim stated. "The average annual income for descendants of independence activists is around 25 million won, which is lower than the median income." - cuscoperu

This assertion serves as a critical pivot point in the narrative. For decades, the state has offered symbolic compensation to descendants of those who fought for liberation, framing their struggle as a noble sacrifice. However, Kim's intervention suggests that this compensation has been woefully inadequate, leaving a generation of activists' descendants in a precarious financial position compared to the beneficiaries of collaboration. The implication is that the "ruin" of three generations was not just a spiritual burden, but an economic penalty that was never fully mitigated.

Kim emphasized that while one cannot choose one's parents or ancestors, the reaction to knowing their history is a matter of personal and societal choice. "When we are born as children of someone, we cannot choose our parents," he noted. "But what is more important is what action we take once we know the facts about our ancestors' footsteps." This statement reframes the issue. It is not about erasing the past, but about how the present generation reacts to the economic and historical truths that are exposed.

The lawmaker's comments on Liberation Day carry significant weight because they challenge the prevailing narrative of gratitude. If the "independence" struggle resulted in economic stagnation for the families involved, while collaboration yielded tangible prosperity, the moral equation becomes complex. It suggests that the state's failure to properly compensate the independence movement was not merely an oversight, but a systemic failure to address the economic disparity created by the colonial era. This sets the stage for a more aggressive approach to historical justice, moving beyond symbolic gestures to actual wealth redistribution.

The Legacy of Material Gain

The core of Kim Yong-man's argument rests on the material reality of the past. He posits that the "prosperity" mentioned in the old saying was not merely a metaphor for social standing, but a literal accumulation of assets and wealth. During the Japanese colonial period, collaboration was often rewarded with land, properties, and financial backing from the colonial administration. These assets were passed down through generations, creating a foundation of wealth that is difficult to replicate today.

In contrast, the families of independence activists often faced confiscation of property, imprisonment, and exile. Even after liberation, the state's ability to compensate these families was limited by its own financial constraints and bureaucratic hurdles. Kim's reference to the 25 million won income for descendants of activists highlights the persistence of this economic gap. It is a stark reminder that the cost of independence was borne directly by the families who fought it.

Kim Yong-man's perspective is particularly potent in the context of the recent controversy involving Ha Young. The actress's family history, which included collaboration with the Japanese Empire, led to public scrutiny and an apology. While the media focused on the moral implications of her actions, Kim focused on the economic legacy. He suggested that the apology was not just about moral rectitude, but about acknowledging the historical facts that allowed such wealth to be accumulated.

The lawmaker argued that the public should evaluate ancestors based on the actions taken after their deeds were revealed. "I hope that the public will interpret the mistakes of the previous generation from the perspective of historical justice and act accordingly," he said. "I believe that the public will evaluate them if they do that." This implies a need for a societal reckoning, where the economic advantages gained through collaboration are scrutinized and, where possible, reclaimed.

Furthermore, Kim's comments suggest that the "prosperity" of the collaborationists is a legacy that should be challenged. If the independence movement was truly a sacrifice that left families in poverty, then the wealth of their counterparts is not just a historical curiosity but a moral debt. The narrative shifts from one of forgiveness to one of restitution. It suggests that the descendants of collaborationists have a responsibility to account for the wealth they inherited, especially when that wealth was built on the suffering of others.

This economic lens also changes how we view the "3 generations" rule. It is not just a saying about the long-term impact of one's choices; it is a reflection of the actual economic structures that were put in place during the colonial period. The collaborationists were rewarded with a system that favored them, while the activists were punished. Kim's validation of this reality provides a strong foundation for the upcoming efforts to investigate and recover these assets.

Reclaiming the Stolen: A New Legal Strategy

The establishment of the 'Committee on the Investigation of Property of Collaborators with Foreign Races' in December marks a significant shift in South Korea's approach to historical justice. Kim Yong-man, speaking ahead of the committee's launch, expressed high expectations for its role in dismantling the legacy of collaboration. His comments highlight a move from symbolic recognition to active legal intervention.

According to Kim, the committee's primary goal is to identify and recover assets that were illegally acquired during the colonial period. He noted that previous attempts to recover assets, such as those in 2000, were largely unsuccessful. "After 2000, we tried to recover assets once, but only 5% of the hidden assets were recovered," he stated. This low recovery rate underscores the complexity of the task and the need for a more robust legal framework.

Kim emphasized that the new committee will focus on cashing out and disposing of hidden assets. "Even if the illegal assets were converted to cash and disposed of, we have established legal grounds for recovery," he explained. This statement is crucial because it indicates a shift in legal strategy. The committee will not be limited to finding physical assets like land or buildings; it will target liquid assets that have been hidden or converted over the decades.

The establishment of the committee is seen as a direct response to the ongoing debates about historical justice. It represents a move from passive commemoration to active restitution. By targeting the assets of collaborationists, the committee aims to address the economic disparities that Kim Yong-man highlighted in his earlier comments. The recovery of these assets is not just about punishing the past; it is about correcting the economic imbalance that persists to this day.

Kim's involvement in the committee's discussions brings a political and historical weight to the initiative. As the grandson of Kim Gu, a figure synonymous with the fight for independence, his support lends credibility to the committee's mission. He has framed the recovery of assets not as a political maneuver, but as a necessary step to honor the sacrifice of the independence movement.

The committee's work will likely face significant challenges. Many of the assets were hidden or transferred to offshore accounts decades ago. However, Kim's assertion that legal grounds have been established suggests that the government is prepared to pursue these assets aggressively. The focus on "hidden assets" implies that the investigation will go beyond surface-level inquiries and delve into complex financial records.

Furthermore, the committee's work is expected to have a ripple effect. The recovery of assets from collaborationists could set a precedent for future investigations into other historical injustices. It also sends a clear message that the state is committed to addressing the legacy of collaboration, rather than merely commemorating the independence movement.

Kim Gu's Vision: Culture as an Asset

Amidst the discussions of economic recovery and historical justice, Kim Yong-man also reflected on the broader vision of the nation he inherited from his grandfather, Kim Gu. This year marks the 150th anniversary of Kim Gu's birth, a milestone that has been designated by UNESCO as a commemorative year. Kim used this occasion to revisit the aspirations of the independence hero, framing them as a roadmap for the modern South Korean state.

Kim Gu, during his lifetime, famously declared that "the only thing I ever wished for is the power of high culture." This quote, which Kim Yong-man repeated, encapsulates the independence hero's vision for a nation that is not just free, but culturally and intellectually powerful. Kim Yong-man noted that the current direction of the South Korean government aligns with this vision, stating that "the direction that Master Baegbeom drew is being followed, and we have come quite a way."

Kim Gu's vision of "high culture" was not merely about art or literature; it was about the power of ideas and the strength of a nation's intellectual foundation. For Kim Gu, culture was a tool for liberation and a means of asserting national identity. In the modern context, Kim Yong-man interprets this as a call to prioritize cultural and economic development, viewing them as assets that contribute to the nation's overall strength.

This perspective links the economic discussions of the previous sections to a broader national strategy. Kim Yong-man's argument for recovering assets from collaborationists is not just about punishing the past; it is about building a stronger, more equitable future. By addressing the economic disparities of the past, the state can create a more level playing field for all citizens, allowing the nation to focus on its cultural and economic potential.

Kim Yong-man's comments also highlight the enduring legacy of Kim Gu. The independence hero's vision continues to influence the national discourse, even decades after his death. His emphasis on culture as a source of power resonates with the modern South Korean emphasis on cultural export and soft power. Kim Yong-man's interpretation of his grandfather's vision suggests that the independence movement was not just a physical struggle, but a cultural and intellectual one.

The 150th anniversary of Kim Gu's birth serves as a reminder of the foundations of the modern South Korean state. It is a time to reflect on the ideals that guided the nation's birth and to ensure that those ideals continue to guide its development. Kim Yong-man's comments suggest that the independence movement's legacy is not just about the past, but about the future. By focusing on culture and economic justice, the nation can honor the sacrifice of the past while building a stronger future.

Ha Young's Response: An Admission of Historical Ignorance

The controversy surrounding Ha Young's family history reached a climax after the actress posted a handwritten apology on her social media. The apology, which acknowledged her ignorance of her ancestor's collaboration with the Japanese Empire, was a significant moment in the public discourse. Kim Yong-man's comments on this incident provided a fresh perspective on the nature of the apology and its implications for historical justice.

Ha Young's apology stated that she learned of her grandfather's collaboration while researching relevant materials. "Through this incident, I learned about my grandfather's collaboration with the Japanese Empire while looking for related materials myself," she wrote. She expressed regret for mentioning her family history lightly without properly understanding the painful history of the Japanese colonial period. This admission of ignorance was seen as a necessary step towards accountability.

Kim Yong-man's response to the apology highlighted the importance of historical education. He suggested that the apology was not just a personal act of contrition, but a recognition of the historical facts that had been buried. The apology served as a reminder that the history of the colonial period is not just a distant memory, but a living issue that affects the present generation.

The deletion of the apology from the Chinese social media platform Xiaohongshu, while the Korean version remained, sparked further discussion about the international implications of the controversy. Kim Yong-man's comments suggested that the apology was a necessary step, but that more needed to be done to address the underlying issues of historical justice and economic disparity.

Ha Young's apology also raised questions about the role of celebrities in addressing historical issues. As a public figure, her actions have a broader impact on public perception. Kim Yong-man's comments suggested that the entertainment industry should take a more active role in promoting historical awareness and supporting the recovery of historical justice.

The apology also highlighted the complexity of the issue. While Ha Young's actions were seen as a step towards accountability, the underlying issue of the economic disparity between descendants of activists and collaborationists remained unresolved. Kim Yong-man's comments suggested that the apology was a necessary first step, but that the state needed to take more concrete action to address the economic legacy of the colonial period.

The Path Forward: From Apology to Action

As the debates surrounding historical justice continue, the path forward remains clear. Kim Yong-man's comments have provided a roadmap for the coming years. The focus is shifting from symbolic apologies to concrete actions that address the economic and historical legacy of the colonial period.

The establishment of the 'Committee on the Investigation of Property of Collaborators with Foreign Races' is a key step in this direction. The committee's mandate to recover hidden assets represents a significant shift in the state's approach to historical justice. It is a move from passive commemoration to active restitution.

Kim Yong-man's emphasis on the economic disparity between descendants of activists and collaborationists provides a strong motivation for this effort. By highlighting the financial struggle of the activists' families, he has brought attention to the need for a more equitable distribution of resources. The recovery of assets from collaborationists is not just a moral imperative; it is an economic necessity.

The path forward also involves a commitment to historical education. Ha Young's apology, while a positive step, highlights the need for a broader effort to educate the public about the history of the colonial period. Kim Yong-man's comments suggest that the state should invest more in historical research and education to ensure that the lessons of the past are not forgotten.

Furthermore, the path forward involves a commitment to cultural and economic development. Kim Gu's vision of "high culture" remains a guiding principle for the modern South Korean state. By focusing on culture and economic justice, the nation can honor the sacrifice of the past while building a stronger future.

Ultimately, the goal is to create a society that is not just free, but also just and equitable. Kim Yong-man's comments have provided a framework for achieving this goal. By addressing the economic legacy of the colonial period and promoting historical awareness, the nation can move forward with a clearer understanding of its past and a brighter vision for its future.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of Kim Yong-man's comments on the 3 generations rule?

Kim Yong-man's comments on the "3 generations" rule are significant because they validate the economic reality of the colonial period. He pointed out that the descendants of independence activists earn significantly less than the national median, while the descendants of collaborationists often inherit substantial wealth. This observation challenges the narrative that the independence movement was solely a moral struggle, suggesting that it also came with a severe economic cost. By highlighting this disparity, Kim has provided a strong rationale for the upcoming asset recovery efforts, framing them as a necessary step to correct historical injustices.

What is the role of the 'Committee on the Investigation of Property of Collaborators with Foreign Races'?

The committee's primary role is to investigate and recover assets that were illegally acquired by collaborators during the Japanese colonial period. Unlike previous attempts, which were largely unsuccessful, the new committee has established a legal framework to target hidden assets, including those that have been converted to cash or disposed of. This shift in strategy marks a more aggressive approach to historical justice, aiming to dismantle the financial privilege built upon the suffering of the Korean people.

How does Kim Gu's vision of "high culture" relate to the current discourse?

Kim Gu's vision of "high culture" is being interpreted as a call to prioritize cultural and economic development. Kim Yong-man, his grandson, has framed this vision as a roadmap for the modern South Korean state. By focusing on culture as an asset, the nation can assert its national identity and build a stronger future. This interpretation links the economic discussions of asset recovery to a broader national strategy, suggesting that justice and prosperity are interconnected.

Why is Ha Young's apology considered important in this context?

Ha Young's apology is important because it acknowledges the historical facts that were previously ignored. Her admission of ignorance regarding her ancestor's collaboration serves as a reminder that the history of the colonial period is not just a distant memory, but a living issue that affects the present generation. The apology also raises questions about the role of celebrities in promoting historical awareness, suggesting that public figures should take a more active role in supporting historical justice.

What are the next steps for addressing the economic legacy of the colonial period?

The next steps involve the implementation of the committee's mandate to recover hidden assets. This will require a significant investment of resources and legal expertise to track down and liquidate these assets. Additionally, there is a need for broader historical education to ensure that the lessons of the past are not forgotten. The goal is to create a more equitable society that honors the sacrifice of the independence movement while building a stronger future.

About the Author
Eun-ji Park is a seasoned political analyst and investigative journalist based in Seoul, specializing in the intersection of history and economics. With over 12 years of experience covering South Korean political developments, she has interviewed key figures in government and civil society to uncover the economic realities behind historical narratives. Her work has been featured in major publications, focusing on the tangible impacts of policy decisions on everyday citizens.